Introduction – What is a Permanent Establishment?
A “Permanent Establishment” (PE) is a concept used in international tax law to determine if a business must pay taxes in a foreign country.
It establishes the criteria for when a business has a taxable presence in a country where it operates, even if the company is based elsewhere.
Understanding PE is important for businesses operating across borders, as it directly impacts where and how much tax a company needs to pay.
This guide will explain what a PE is, why it matters, and how companies can ensure they are compliant with the rules. We will also provide a practical example to illustrate the concept.
What is a Permanent Establishment?
In simple terms, a Permanent Establishment is a fixed place of business through which a company carries out its operations in a foreign country.
Once a company is deemed to have a PE in a country, it becomes liable to pay taxes on the profits generated in that country.
Most tax treaties and national laws follow a similar framework for defining PE. Generally, a business has a PE if:
- It operates from a fixed place of business in another country (such as an office, branch, or factory); or
- It has a dependent agent in the foreign country who regularly concludes contracts or conducts business on behalf of the company.
Why is PE Important?
The concept of PE is vital because it prevents businesses from avoiding taxes in countries where they are actively earning income.
Without these rules, companies could exploit loopholes, shifting profits to low-tax jurisdictions while generating revenue in high-tax countries.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) guidelines on PE form the basis for many international tax treaties.
These rules ensure that businesses pay their fair share of tax in the countries where they have a real presence and carry out economic activities.
Key Features of a Permanent Establishment
The determination of whether a company has a PE depends on several factors, including:
- Fixed Place of Business: A PE generally exists when a business has a physical office, branch, or factory in a foreign country. This presence must be somewhat permanent, not just temporary or occasional.
- Agent or Employee: Even if a company does not have a physical office, it can still create a PE if it has an agent or employee in the foreign country who is authorised to conclude contracts or regularly performs business on the company’s behalf.
- Exemptions: Some activities, like storing goods or conducting market research, may not create a PE, even if they occur in a foreign country. These activities are often considered “preparatory” or “auxiliary” and are excluded from the PE definition.
Example of a Permanent Establishment
Imagine a company based in the UK, called “Tech Solutions Ltd.”, that sells software services to customers worldwide. Tech Solutions Ltd. has its main headquarters in London, but it wants to expand its customer base in Germany. To do so, it opens a small office in Berlin where local employees meet with clients and negotiate contracts.
In this case, Tech Solutions Ltd. has created a Permanent Establishment in Germany.
Here’s why:
- The Berlin office is a fixed place of business. It operates continuously and serves as a base for the company’s operations in Germany.
- The employees in Germany are actively involved in negotiating and concluding contracts, which are core business activities.
As a result, Germany has the right to tax the profits that Tech Solutions Ltd. generates through its activities in the country.
Remote Work and PE
The rise of remote work has added new complexities to the concept of PE.
For example, if an employee of a company works from home in a foreign country for an extended period, this could create a PE.
This was seen in a recent Danish case where a Swedish company’s CEO worked part-time in Denmark.
The Danish tax authorities argued that the CEO’s activities created a PE, as they were performing key business functions in Denmark, such as concluding contracts. The court agreed, establishing that the company had a taxable presence in Denmark.
Consequences of Creating a PE
Once a company is determined to have a PE in a foreign country, it must:
- Pay taxes on the profits earned from its activities in that country.
- File tax returns and keep proper records in the foreign country, ensuring compliance with local tax laws.
- Allocate its profits between its home country and the foreign country where it has the PE, often following complex transfer pricing rules.
Failure to comply with PE rules can lead to significant penalties and legal disputes with tax authorities, as well as the possibility of double taxation if the company doesn’t have a treaty between the two countries to avoid this.
Conclusion – What is a Permanent Establishment?
The concept of Permanent Establishment is crucial for any business with cross-border operations.
It ensures that businesses pay their fair share of taxes where they are economically active.
Understanding how and when a company creates a PE is essential for managing international tax risks and staying compliant with tax laws.
Final Thoughts
If you have any queries about this article on Permanent Establishment, or tax matters in your jurisdiction, then please get in touch.
Alternatively, if you are a tax adviser in your jurisdiction and would be interested in sharing your knowledge and becoming a tax native, then there is more information on membership here.