Amazon VAT Evasion Allegations in Italy – Introduction
Tax authorities in Italy have accused Amazon of evading €1.2 billion in Value Added Tax (VAT) on sales from China and other non-EU countries between 2019 and 2021.
The claim suggests that goods sold via Amazon’s platform avoided proper VAT reporting, allowing sellers to underpay tax or avoid it entirely.
This case is part of a larger crackdown on digital platforms suspected of facilitating tax avoidance through complex supply chains and offshore structures.
This isn’t the first time tech giants have clashed with European tax authorities.
The EU has been tightening VAT compliance rules in response to concerns that e-commerce giants give an unfair advantage to overseas sellers by allowing them to avoid local tax obligations.
If Amazon is found guilty, the case could have major implications for online marketplaces operating in the region.
What’s Happening?
The Italian Guardia di Finanza (tax police) and the Agenzia delle Entrate (Revenue Agency) claim that between 2019 and 2021, Amazon acted as an intermediary for thousands of non-EU sellers, predominantly from China, who were not properly registered for VAT in Italy.
This allegedly allowed sellers to undercut local competitors, as they were selling goods at VAT-free prices.
Amazon has denied wrongdoing, stating that it complies with all applicable laws and has invested in systems to identify and block non-compliant sellers.
However, tax authorities argue that the company should have done more to ensure sellers were VAT-registered before listing their products.
Italy has previously targeted other e-commerce giants, including Alibaba and eBay, for similar VAT issues.
In 2019, it was estimated that VAT fraud in the e-commerce sector cost EU governments over €5 billion annually.
Why Does This Matter?
VAT fraud in e-commerce is a significant issue across Europe, as platforms like Amazon have allowed non-EU sellers to access the market without the same tax burdens as domestic businesses.
The EU has introduced new VAT rules, including the One Stop Shop (OSS) system and Marketplaces as Deemed Suppliers regulations, to prevent platforms from facilitating VAT avoidance.
If Italy succeeds in its case, Amazon could be held liable for the unpaid VAT, which might force other countries to take similar legal action.
The case also highlights broader tax policy challenges in the digital economy, particularly who should be responsible for ensuring VAT compliance—the seller or the platform.
Amazon VAT Evasion Allegations in Italy – Conclusion
If Amazon is found guilty of VAT evasion in Italy, the consequences could be significant for the entire e-commerce industry.
More platforms may face pressure to enforce stricter tax compliance rules, and non-compliant sellers could be blocked from EU markets altogether.
For businesses and consumers, this case serves as a reminder that tax compliance in the digital economy is becoming more scrutinised.
Final thoughts
If you have any queries about this article on Amazon VAT Evasion Allegations in Italy, or tax matters in Italy more generally, then please get in touch.
Alternatively, if you are a tax adviser in Italy and would be interested in sharing your knowledge and becoming a tax native, then please get in touch. There is more information on membership here.