Buyback taxes – Introduction
In the Netherlands, a bold new tax proposal is turning heads.
The Dutch government has announced plans to introduce a new tax on share buybacks – a move aimed at reining in what it sees as corporate excess and encouraging businesses to reinvest in their people and the economy.
It’s part of a growing global trend where governments are casting a critical eye on large, wealthy companies and asking: are they doing enough for society?
But what exactly is a share buyback?
And why does the Dutch government think it should be taxed?
What’s a Share Buyback?
Let’s say a company has made a tidy profit. Instead of using that money to build a new factory, pay workers more, or lower prices, the company decides to buy its own shares back from the stock market.
This reduces the number of shares in circulation and often pushes the price up – benefiting shareholders (including top executives) who still hold shares.
It’s a bit like a bakery using its extra cash not to hire more bakers or bake more bread, but to buy up bread tokens from the market to make existing tokens more valuable.
Critics say buybacks prioritise short-term profits and shareholders over long-term investment and workers.
Governments – including the United States and now the Netherlands – are starting to push back.
What’s the Dutch Government Proposing?
The Dutch plan would introduce a 15% tax on share buybacks, mirroring a similar approach taken by the US under President Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act, which added a 1% tax on corporate buybacks in 2023 (with plans to potentially raise it to 4%).
Dutch Finance Minister Steven van Weyenberg said the aim is to “encourage companies to reinvest profits into innovation, jobs, and sustainable practices” instead of simply enriching shareholders.
The move is also part of a broader effort to tackle inequality and the concentration of wealth.
The buyback tax would apply to large publicly listed companies and is currently expected to be introduced in 2025, subject to parliamentary approval.
Supporters vs Critics
Supporters say this is a fair and sensible tax that could bring in much-needed revenue while nudging companies towards more productive investment.
But opponents argue it risks making the Dutch stock market less attractive.
Critics also say companies may simply find other ways to return money to shareholders, such as dividends – which are already taxed, but usually at a lower rate depending on the country.
There’s also concern about double taxation – the company is taxed on its profits, then again when it tries to return value to shareholders.
Is This Part of a Global Trend?
Yes.
The United States was first out of the gate, and other countries are now watching closely.
France and Spain have floated similar ideas.
The EU has also been discussing how best to tax excess profits and corporate behaviour in a way that’s fair and sustainable.
For years, governments have struggled to tax large multinational companies in a meaningful way.
Buybacks are now in the spotlight as one more pressure point – especially when firms are reporting record profits while public services struggle and inequality grows.
Buyback taxes – Conclusion
The Dutch buyback tax might seem technical, but it’s part of a wider debate about the role of big business in society.
Should companies be free to do what they want with their profits – or should governments intervene to shape more equitable outcomes?
One thing is clear: the Netherlands is taking a bold step that may well inspire others.
Final Thoughts
If you have any queries about this article on buyback taxes, or tax matters in the Netherlands then please get in touch.
Alternatively, if you are a tax adviser in the Netherlands and would be interested in sharing your knowledge and becoming a tax native, then there is more information on membership here.