Ireland ‘Tax Scam’ – Introduction
A former advisor to Donald Trump has labelled Ireland a “tax scam,” reigniting debate around Ireland’s corporate tax regime and its attractiveness to multinational corporations.
The comments, while blunt, reflect long-standing international concerns about tax competition and the shifting landscape of global tax rules.
Who Made the Comment and Why?
Stephen Moore, a former Trump economic advisor and prominent US economist, made the remarks during a televised discussion about global taxation.
He referred to Ireland as a “tax scam country” for enabling large US multinationals to significantly lower their tax liabilities through aggressive tax planning.
His comment reflects frustrations in some US political and policy circles that companies like Apple and Google can book enormous profits in low-tax jurisdictions while paying little in their home country.
Ireland’s Corporate Tax Model
Ireland has long maintained a 12.5% corporate tax rate, one of the lowest in the EU.
Coupled with favourable rulings and intellectual property planning structures, this has made Ireland a prime location for US tech and pharma companies to base their European operations.
Although Ireland has moved to align with OECD tax transparency and anti-avoidance standards, its business model remains a contentious issue—especially for larger countries trying to protect their tax base.
Global Response and OECD Reforms
Moore’s comment comes at a time when the OECD’s global tax deal, particularly the global minimum tax under Pillar Two, aims to level the playing field.
Ireland has signed up to the agreement, committing to implement a 15% minimum effective corporate tax rate for large multinationals.
This will, over time, erode some of the incentives that made Ireland such a popular tax jurisdiction. However, critics argue that enforcement will be patchy and that smaller jurisdictions will find new ways to remain competitive.
Is the Criticism Fair?
While the “tax scam” comment is clearly provocative, it highlights real tensions in the international tax system.
Ireland has benefitted enormously from its tax policies, but has also cooperated with global reforms.
The reality is more nuanced than the rhetoric.
Conclusion
Ireland’s role in global tax planning has long attracted scrutiny, and Stephen Moore’s recent remarks have thrown the issue back into the spotlight.
As global reforms take hold, countries like Ireland will need to find new ways to stay competitive while avoiding reputational damage.
Final thoughts
If you have any queries about this article on corporate tax regimes, or tax matters in Ireland then please get in touch.
Alternatively, if you are a tax adviser in Ireland and would be interested in sharing your knowledge and becoming a tax native, then there is more information on membership here.