Cologne Tax Court Adapts German VAT Law – Introduction
In December 2022, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) made a significant ruling (C-378/21 P GmbH) that VAT incorrectly displayed on an invoice does not inherently result in a tax liability, provided that tax revenue is not at risk.
This interpretation of Art. 203 of the VAT Directive has been echoed in Germany for the first time by the Cologne Tax Court in a judgement dated May 27, 2023 (8 K 2452/21), applying it to Section 14c para. 1 of the German VAT Act.
This decision marks a shift in addressing VAT liabilities and showcases the evolving landscape of tax law in the European Union and its member states.
The Essence of the Ruling
The Cologne Tax Court’s decision expands the scope of Section 14c para. 1 of the German VAT Act beyond its traditional application.
Historically, this section was interpreted to possibly implicate a broader range of entities, including those not eligible for input VAT deduction, in tax liabilities.
However, the court’s recent judgement clarifies that if an invoicing party acts in good faith, Section 14c (1) of the German VAT Act does not apply, aligning with the CJEU’s stance on safeguarding tax revenue without unduly penalizing companies.
This judicial interpretation is significant for companies, indicating that invoices need not be corrected in the absence of a tax risk, a principle now supported by both EU and German court decisions.
However, companies must demonstrate the absence of tax risk, particularly challenging when the services involve VAT-exempt entities, such as public authorities and courts, as highlighted in the Advocate General Kokott’s Opinion.
Background and Implications
The CJEU ruling and the subsequent Cologne Tax Court decision stem from a case involving a provider of indoor playground services in Austria, where VAT was incorrectly applied at a standard rate for services that qualified for a reduced tax rate.
The correction of these mistakes raised questions about tax liabilities when the tax revenue was not jeopardized, primarily because the end consumers were not entitled to input VAT deductions.
In Germany, the Cologne Tax Court’s judgement directly addresses how Section 14c of the German VAT Act should be interpreted in light of EU directives, emphasizing the need for tax law to protect companies acting in good faith without risking tax revenue.
This decision not only reflects a harmonization of EU and German tax law but also offers a clearer path for companies navigating VAT compliance and potential liabilities.
Looking Forward
While the Cologne Tax Court’s decision marks a significant development in the interpretation of VAT law in Germany, it is important to note that an appeal against this judgement is pending before the Federal Tax Court (case no. V R 16/23).
The appeal will not challenge the interpretation of Section 14c of the German VAT Act per se but will focus on the applicability of tax exemptions under specific conditions, indicating the ongoing evolution of tax law interpretation in response to EU directives.
Cologne Tax Court Adapts German VAT Law – Conclusion
The recent decisions by the CJEU and the Cologne Tax Court highlight the dynamic nature of tax law in the European Union, emphasizing the importance of aligning national laws with EU directives.
Final thoughts
If you have any queries about this article or any other general German tax matters then please get in touch.